So here we are again I did not want to talk about this until next week but as it stands I have been messaged about this so much Minecraft has gone full 1984 with these Euler changes and have made every single Minecraft server commercial everything of that nature Servers with player cues like 2b2t are now banned videos may be taken down for any reason whatsoever using the word Minecraft in your title of any YouTube video may be taken down there are a lot of things that I have read over this weekend so I am going to Fast Track this Video and make it out right now so what I’m telling you right now is my own interpretation of what I think is going to happen I may be wrong as well as everybody life sucks but I’ll do my best first and foremost there is a lot I do Not like about how this has been handled this is the blog post that was released on the 2nd of August outlining the core changes to the Euler released on the same day as the 23w31a Villager snapshot now which one is more important hard to say snapshot tint really cool Euler changes cool or Not we don’t know but very important which one gets announced on Twitter the snapshot is one being used to mask the other that’s speculative but what happened was all of our eyes were trained on the snapshots which is just understandable isn’t it and what makes this worse is it is our responsibility To check back for these changes these guidelines may change as time goes by we reserve the right to change our minds at any time so don’t count on these guidelines always being here it is up to you to check back to see if these guidelines have changed don’t like it That’s never the way it should be no no okay moving on as with any legal document we look at the purpose this is all fluff text don’t worry about it these guidelines are to explain what we consider to be acceptable ways to use the Minecraft name brand Assets in your Creation what has actually changed in these guidelines compared to the one in 2020. this is from the internet archive right here last updated April 22 T20 to make this as concise as I can I’m going to cover all of the bases that people are worried about it can kind of be Outlined here with this tweet but I have been messaged by Kian who runs the gun server and these are some of the concerns that he has outlined things like 2b2t being non-compliant moyang taking down things that they don’t like running disclaimers AKA your server is not Minecraft official not using Minecraft in the title of your YouTube video every server now being considered commercial servers must be kid friendly servers must have a terms of service clause and a few others but let’s get into each one in detail 2b2t is now non-euler compliant under the preview of this subclause access to your server Can’t be limited to or controlled by a player owning or having access to out of game content products or services and the service in argument is this the player queue so this is a graph here this is number of players online we’ve got about 400 people right now players In queue we have about 200 and in the priority queue we have three now what is the priority queue welcome to the official 2b2t shop thank you for visiting here you can purchase priority queue status for your account which lets you join the server faster and it lasts For one month 1999 USD I would assume and yes it absolutely lets you join the server faster considering just how many people are waiting to join the server right now does this contravene this sub clause about the server controlling player access by having out of game content or Services honestly I don’t Know these Provisions are so confusing that I cannot interpret this with Clarity you may charge for Access absolutely provided that the cost is the same for everyone and given this is the same cost for everyone it’s okay I truly believe this is for people who own a certain product or service that cannot Be purchased by someone else so if this Q jumping service is not purchasable by some people then yes I’d do think 2b2t is breaking the usage guidelines this is a bit iffy for 2b2t but anyway we’ll get into that any server piece of online content such as video or other may be Taken down for any reason whatsoever you might think I’m going to talk about this but I won’t because this is actually from the previous iteration from 2020 and it reads the same way maybe revoked at any time if we think it is appropriate or we don’t like what you’re Doing there have been instances where I have heard rumors of videos being taken down by moyang or Microsoft some of these unsubstantiated but this is still giving moyang the ability to do it so if you didn’t like it then you won’t like it now by the way I’m going to repeat This later on in the video I hate the way this is worded we don’t like what you are doing that sounds like unbridled power to me using Minecraft as a significant part of a creative work such as a YouTube video is no longer allowed So this is the big one can you use the word Minecraft in your title anymore the old phrase was you may use our name in the secondary or main title and you do so because it is necessary to honestly and fairly describe those things or the Purpose of them you ensure that the name is not the dominant element or distinctive parts so what has changed now it says this so the honest purpose and fair description stuff that’s all moved down to the secondary title and the dominant title now has the presumption that you may not use it so Things have been shifted and moved around which does change the way this entire Clause is read see here there’s a presumption that you can you may use our name but here it says you may not to help you we’ve suggested some examples and these examples are here too so the Shaft of Minecraft podcast and then Minecraft the ultimate help app and by the way notice here they changed it from Minecraft here to Minecrafters and this is absolutely intentional the shaft a minecrafter’s podcast they’re okay with that but are they okay with the shaft a Minecraft podcast probably not anymore Now let me assure you the addition of two new examples is completely intentional there’s a reason they’ve done that on the contrary these Provisions did exist in the older version of the guidelines which leads me to believe I don’t really think they are gutsy enough to start taking down videos With the word Minecraft in the title even if it’s the dominant word interpreting the word dominant is going to be an issue and you also got to read this within the purpose of the text they want to protect their brand I don’t know this is also unclear any server is Considered commercial under every circumstance even if it does not make money or not so this is where it comes into a little bit of Doubt again when you do commercial things you must follow the commercial use guidelines this applies for example if you want to set up or run non-commercial blogs servers Like hold on you must follow the commercial use guidelines if you do non-commercial things I swear while I like this whole paragraph dot Point format I wish they would go and do something like this I do know what you’re trying to say here you’re saying non-commercial things must now follow Commercial guidelines but you’re only forcing rules here just make it a little bit clearer so there are quite a few commercial use guidelines there’s so much to read through here I’m not going to make this an hour long video you guys don’t have the time for that but here is One service with any content not suitable for 10 year olds no longer allowed remember these are publicly shared servers not private servers or servers entitlements and advertising are suitable for audiences of all ages for example gambling pornography violence terrorism explicit lyrics unsafe mature content there are quite a few things Here these are mostly not new it’s just that they’ve added a few additional things violence terrorism explicit lyrics unsafe mature content look here’s the thing I honestly do not think a lot of server owners have been following these rules and it’s just too hard to enforce man is 2v2t breaking these Guidelines probably as long as your server videos live streams products use the Minecraft brand and in a positive way they shouldn’t get rid of you and then this brings into question freedom of speech that is why I hate this so much just don’t worry like this I wish They didn’t wear it like that what to say um I don’t know how to end this video and I know the comments are going to be extremely divided but I just want to make things as clear as I can I am not taking sides especially with the chat Reporting thing I’ve said that it’s just a move that’s required legally and they were never really gonna use it it has been used I’ve I’ve seen examples of it being used as it turns out it’s been relatively quiet as I expected but I’m glad a lot of noise was made because it Needed to be made for the initial system to be fixed so while these changes a bit concerning yeah they probably are but they always have been the real issue here is that Microsoft and moyang hold the sword and they have all of the power in the world to use it at any point Personally I don’t think they’ll go too far with it but I don’t know that and we don’t know that Video Information
This video, titled ‘Have Mojang gone too far with the new user guidelines? (August 2023)’, was uploaded by Phoenix SC on 2023-08-07 02:30:02. It has garnered 841965 views and 55219 likes. The duration of the video is 00:08:58 or 538 seconds.
New guidelines (August 2023): https://www.minecraft.net/en-us/usage-guidelines Old guidelines (April 2020): https://web.archive.org/web/20220630195558/https://www.minecraft.net/en-us/terms
Merch: https://phoenixsc.store/ Cape: https://store.badlion.net/shop/PhoenixSC
——————————————————————– This channel is powered by Shockbyte server hosting —
Receive a 25% discount on your first month on a server with code “PHOENIXSC”! https://shockbyte.com/partner/phoenixsc
——————————————————————–
If you’d like to monetarily support the channel, consider joining as a member! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCj4zC1Hfj-uc90FUXzRamNw/join
SECOND CHANNEL: https://www.youtube.com/phoenixsucksat TWITTER: http://twitter.com/phnixhamsta TWITCH: http://www.twitch.tv/phoenixsclive WEBSITE: http://phoenixsc.me FACEBOOK: http://facebook.com/phnixhamstasc
#Minecraft is a game about breaking and placing blocks, developed by Mojang. Minecraft: https://minecraft.net/
#PhoenixSC #Creative